Automation
How to Calculate ROI on Automation Before You Invest
Wisconsin workflow consultant explains how to identify costly inefficiencies and measure whether AI and automation investments will actually pay off.
Key takeaways
- Small inefficiencies like document searches can cost organizations thousands of hours annually when multiplied across all employees.
- Establishing baseline measurements for time, costs, and errors is essential before calculating automation ROI—without it, returns are largely assumptions.
- Recovered time creates productivity value that differs from direct cost savings, particularly for growing companies that need capacity without proportional headcount increases.
- Strong automation candidates involve repetitive data entry, frequent approvals, or recurring errors rather than tasks requiring significant human judgment.
- Starting with one high-friction process allows businesses to learn from implementation before expanding automation efforts.
Why it matters
Businesses face mounting pressure to adopt AI and automation, but most lack a framework for determining which processes justify investment. Without baseline measurements of current inefficiencies, return on investment becomes guesswork—leading to either paralysis or costly mistakes.
The Hidden Cost of Small Inefficiencies
Ten minutes spent searching for a document doesn't feel like a crisis. But when 50 employees repeat that search daily, the company loses more than 2,000 hours annually—time that could be spent on revenue-generating work or strategic initiatives.
These small inefficiencies—processing invoices manually, tracking down approvals, rekeying information—accumulate across organizations in ways that rarely trigger alarm bells. Yet they represent some of the most addressable opportunities for improving profitability.
"We don't adopt technology because it's fun; we look for solutions to problems that help us grow," said Alex Zaban, vice president of sales at James Imaging Systems, a Brookfield-based provider of digital workflow automation solutions.
Start With Measurement, Not Technology
Zaban recommends businesses examine workflows from two perspectives before considering automation investments: the client experience and internal operations.
For clients, the questions are straightforward: How much friction exists in communication and delivery? What delays do they experience?
Internally, the focus shifts to identifying where information gets rekeyed, where searches consume time, and where manual routing creates bottlenecks. The goal is establishing a baseline that quantifies current costs in time, errors, and missed opportunities.
"Without that baseline, ROI is largely an assumption," Zaban explained. "With it, we can set a realistic scope, explain what should improve and how we estimate the value, and know what to measure after implementation."
Employees often prove invaluable in this discovery process. They've typically developed workarounds for inefficient processes that have become normalized over time.
ROI Extends Beyond Direct Cost Savings
While many businesses focus on expense reduction when evaluating automation, Zaban emphasizes that recovered time creates different kinds of value.
Direct financial benefits occur when automation eliminates overtime, reduces expenses, or avoids an otherwise necessary hire. But productivity gains—freeing employees for higher-value work—matter just as much, particularly for growing companies.
"When you use technology to give time back to a trusted employee instead of just hiring more people, you grow vertically, not horizontally," Zaban said.
For a company scaling from 50 to 150 employees, processes that once worked adequately can become unmanageable. Automation helps organizations handle increased transaction volumes and serve more clients without proportionally expanding administrative staff.
Other returns include faster client response times, fewer errors, improved compliance, and better operational visibility—benefits that may not appear on a balance sheet but directly affect competitiveness.
Where to Begin
Not every process justifies automation investment. Zaban recommends evaluating how frequently a process occurs, how much time or money it consumes, and whether improving it would meaningfully affect employees, clients, or growth.
Processes involving repetitive data entry, frequent approvals, or recurring errors typically make strong candidates. Tasks requiring significant human judgment or that change constantly may not.
For businesses uncertain where to start, Zaban suggests identifying one process creating substantial friction for employees or clients, fixing it, learning from the implementation, and building from there.
"The companies that pull ahead won't be the ones that waited for the perfect plan," he said. "They'll be the ones that started."
These details were first reported by BizTimes Milwaukee, which profiled James Imaging Systems' approach to helping Wisconsin businesses evaluate automation investments.