Policy
DOJ Refers Two Attorneys for Bar Discipline Over AI Misuse
One lawyer submitted fabricated AI quotes to court while another violated protective order by uploading documents to public AI platform.
Key takeaways
- DOJ's ethics office referred two federal attorneys for potential bar discipline over separate AI-related violations in government legal work
- One attorney filed a brief with fabricated AI-generated quotes and then lied to the court about it
- Another lawyer breached a protective order by uploading confidential documents to a public AI platform
- The referrals mark the first known cases of DOJ lawyers facing formal ethics consequences specifically for AI misuse
- Bar authorities will now determine appropriate sanctions, which could include reprimands, suspension, or disbarment
The Justice Department's Office of Professional Responsibility has referred two federal attorneys for potential bar discipline following separate incidents involving improper use of artificial intelligence tools, according to anonymized investigation summaries released this week.
The cases represent the first known instances of DOJ lawyers facing formal ethics referrals specifically tied to AI usage in their official duties, marking a significant development as legal professionals across the country grapple with the technology's risks and limitations.
The violations
In the first case, an attorney filed a brief containing AI-generated content that included fabricated quotations. When questioned by the court, the lawyer compounded the problem by making false statements about the document's origins. The Office of Professional Responsibility determined this conduct warranted referral to bar authorities for potential disciplinary action.
The second attorney violated a tribunal court's protective order by uploading confidential documents into a publicly accessible AI platform. Protective orders typically restrict how sensitive case materials can be shared or stored, and using a public AI service exposed the documents beyond authorized parties.
Why it matters
These referrals signal that AI-related mistakes in legal work now carry formal professional consequences, not just embarrassment. As generative AI tools become standard in law offices, the incidents establish that attorneys cannot blame technology for ethical failures. Bar associations and courts are drawing clear lines: lawyers remain personally responsible for verifying AI output and protecting client information, regardless of which tools they use. The Justice Department's willingness to discipline its own attorneys also sets a precedent that may influence how other legal employers and regulators approach AI governance.
Growing scrutiny
The findings reflect broader concerns within the legal profession about artificial intelligence reliability. Courts nationwide have encountered cases where lawyers submitted briefs citing nonexistent cases generated by AI chatbots, leading judges to impose sanctions and prompting bar associations to issue guidance on responsible AI use.
The Justice Department's ethics office published the investigation summaries in anonymized form, following its standard practice of protecting attorney identities while making findings public. The referrals mean state bar authorities will now determine whether the conduct warrants formal sanctions, which could range from reprimands to suspension or disbarment depending on severity.
Legal ethics experts have warned that attorneys using AI tools must verify all output, maintain confidentiality obligations, and ensure compliance with court rules—responsibilities that remain unchanged regardless of technological assistance.
These details were first reported by Bloomberg Law.