Policy

Defiance Act Stalls in House Despite Senate Passage

Paris Hilton and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez push for federal civil remedies against AI-generated sexual deepfakes as House leadership delays vote.

Omega Editorial · November 18, 2026 · 3 min read

Key takeaways

  • The Defiance Act would create a federal civil right to sue creators and distributors of nonconsensual AI sexual deepfakes.
  • The Senate passed the bill unanimously in January 2026, but the House has not voted after two years despite bipartisan support.
  • Current federal law criminalizes deepfake pornography but leaves victims without independent civil legal remedies.
  • The bill has 70 House cosponsors evenly split between parties, with 117 organizational endorsements including major tech companies.
  • Political reluctance to give Rep. Ocasio-Cortez a legislative win before midterms may have contributed to the delay, according to reporting.

Push for federal deepfake legislation intensifies

Paris Hilton returned to Capitol Hill on Tuesday alongside Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Rep. Laurel Lee to demand House action on the Defiance Act, bipartisan legislation that would create a federal civil right to sue perpetrators of AI-generated sexual deepfakes. The Senate passed the bill by unanimous consent in January 2026, but the House has not held a vote after two years of advocacy efforts, according to details first reported by CNBC.

The proposed law would allow victims to sue anyone who creates, shares, publishes, solicits, or threatens to distribute sexually explicit deepfakes without consent. Survivors could recover legal costs and obtain court orders requiring content removal. The measure aims to close gaps in existing federal protections by establishing clear civil remedies beyond criminal prosecution.

Current law leaves enforcement gaps

The Take It Down Act, signed by President Trump in May 2025, made nonconsensual intimate images including AI deepfakes a federal crime and required covered platforms to remove reported content within 48 hours. That legislation followed a 2024 case in Aledo, Texas, where a 14-year-old girl's Instagram photo was altered to appear nude and circulated on Snapchat.

But critics say criminal enforcement alone proves insufficient. Victims must rely on federal prosecutors to bring cases and lack independent legal recourse. State laws offer inconsistent protections, and many don't explicitly address synthetic images.

Hilton, who serves as chief advocacy officer at digital identity protection firm Loti AI, said her company has detected more than 100,000 explicit deepfakes depicting her and helped remove over 60,000. "I'm very fortunate that I have a team of lawyers. I have people helping me. But a lot of these young girls and women don't have that support," she told CNBC's Changemakers podcast.

Political dynamics block House vote

The Defiance Act has 70 House cosponsors split evenly between 35 Democrats and 35 Republicans. House Speaker Mike Johnson called it "good policy" in September but said the chamber had not built consensus. A July Politico report indicated some Republicans were reluctant to give Ocasio-Cortez, who introduced the House companion bill in May 2025, a legislative win before midterm elections. Specific objections from members have not been made public.

The Sexual Violence Prevention Association, which helped author the legislation, delivered letters to Johnson and House Majority Leader Steve Scalise on Tuesday urging a floor vote. The bill has received 117 endorsements including Microsoft, Snap, and OpenAI.

If the House doesn't act before the current Congress ends, supporters must reintroduce the measure in January. Democrats are projected to hold a House majority in the next Congress, though the exact margin remains uncertain.

Why it matters

AI tools have made creating convincing sexual deepfakes trivial and scalable, turning any photo into explicit content within seconds. Victims—disproportionately women and minors—face harassment, reputational damage, and psychological trauma with limited legal recourse. The gap between technological capability and legal protection leaves perpetrators facing few consequences while survivors struggle to remove content and hold creators accountable. Federal civil remedies would give victims direct legal standing independent of criminal prosecution, establishing clearer deterrents in an enforcement landscape that currently depends on prosecutorial discretion and platform cooperation.

These details were first reported by CNBC.

  • #deepfakes
  • #ai regulation
  • #defiance act
  • #nonconsensual imagery
  • #content moderation
  • #digital rights

This is an original analysis by the Omega editorial team. Source reporting: AI Watch.

Want systems like this working for your business?

Book a Call

More in Policy