Policy

Colleges Deploy AI in Admissions With No Governance Rules

Public records requests reveal universities lack policies governing automated review of applications, essays, and financial aid decisions.

Omega Editorial · November 18, 2026 · 4 min read

Key takeaways

  • No public university has established an AI governance policy specifically for admissions, according to public records requests filed by Student Defense.
  • Georgia Tech processes nearly 68,000 applications using AI to review up to 150,000 transcripts, saving three to five minutes per application.
  • Colleges are using AI not just for transcript review but also to flag AI-generated essays, sort applicants, and help determine financial aid packages.
  • Spelman College President Ayanna Howard warns that AI trained on historical data could disadvantage students who don't match established admission patterns.
  • Student Defense has developed a "Student AI Bill of Rights" calling for mandatory disclosure of AI use in admissions decisions.

Universities across the United States are deploying artificial intelligence throughout their admissions processes — from transcript review to essay evaluation to financial aid recommendations — without formal governance policies in place, according to findings first reported by GBH News.

Public records requests filed by Student Defense, a legal and advocacy nonprofit, found that no public university had established an AI governance policy specifically addressing admissions. The discovery comes as institutions face budget pressures and declining enrollment, prompting administrators to automate tasks previously handled by human staff.

How colleges are using the technology

Georgia Tech began using AI this fall to process grades and test scores for nearly 68,000 applicants competing for approximately 4,100 spots. The volume creates significant administrative burden: students often attend multiple high schools or dual-enroll at colleges, generating up to 150,000 transcripts for a single admissions cycle.

"This is perfunctory, soul-sucking work that ideally you could not have humans doing," said Rick Clark, vice president of enrollment management at Georgia Tech. The university estimates its transcript-sorting technology saves three to five minutes per application.

Institutions are also using AI to flag potentially AI-generated essays, sort applicants by academic metrics, and in some cases make complete admissions recommendations. The technology extends to financial aid determinations, where algorithms estimate what families can afford and how much they might be willing to pay.

Why it matters

The absence of governance frameworks raises fundamental questions about fairness, transparency, and bias in college admissions. AI systems trained on historical admissions data could systematically disadvantage students who don't match established patterns — a particular concern for underrepresented groups. Without disclosure requirements, applicants have no way to know how algorithms are evaluating their applications or what biases might be embedded in the systems. As the Trump administration explores using AI tools to investigate alleged discrimination in admissions, the lack of oversight creates regulatory uncertainty for institutions already deploying these technologies.

Concerns about bias and transparency

Spelman College President Ayanna Howard, author of "Rebooting the Machines," warns that AI systems could disadvantage non-traditional applicants. "If you do not look like the students that have been admitted in prior cycles and have been successful, the AI might not tag you as being of high rank," Howard said.

Aaron Ament, president of Student Defense, attributes the automation surge to budget cuts and declining state support. "They're seeing where they can cut costs, and then use AI not just to replace a lot of human functions and save money in the administration of college — recruitment and admissions — but then also try to get as much tuition dollars as they can out of students," Ament said.

His organization has developed a "Student AI Bill of Rights" calling on colleges to disclose if, when, and how they use AI to evaluate applicants.

Industry defends current practices

Joseph Miller, who leads the National Association of College Admissions Counselors Admissions Practices Committee, said AI usage varies widely among institutions. Some have abandoned the tools entirely and hired additional human reviewers, while others like Virginia Tech have used them for years.

Georgia Tech's Clark emphasized that AI handles administrative tasks but doesn't make final decisions. "No, 100%, AI is not making admission decisions — not making financial aid decisions," he said. The university uses a trained chatbot for routine questions, freeing staff to focus on relationship-building with prospective students.

On Monday, former Justice Department Civil Rights division chief Harmeet K. Dhillon said the Trump administration is considering AI tools to analyze admissions data for discrimination investigations, though within existing government policy constraints.

These details were first reported by Kirk Carapezza for GBH News.

  • #college admissions
  • #ai governance
  • #higher education
  • #algorithmic bias
  • #financial aid
  • #education policy

This is an original analysis by the Omega editorial team. Source reporting: AI Watch.

Want systems like this working for your business?

Book a Call

More in Policy